Guide for renters
Moving totes vs cardboard boxes: which is right for you?
Cardboard boxes have been the default for a long time, and they still work. Reusable plastic moving totes are a different approach: they arrive ready to use and leave when you are done. Here is an honest comparison so you can pick what fits your move.
Updated
The short version
Totes trade a little planning up front (you book delivery and pickup dates) for a lot less hassle later. No folding, no tape, no flattening, and no pile of boxes to deal with after the move. Cardboard is easy to find and you can keep it as long as you like, but it takes more work on both ends of a move.
Setup and packing
Cardboard boxes need to be assembled and taped before you can pack them, and taped again to close them. Rental totes are ready the moment they arrive. Most have attached lids that close without tape, which makes packing faster and makes it easy to open a tote again when you need something you already packed.
Totes are a uniform size, which makes estimating easier. Cardboard comes in many sizes, which can be useful for odd shaped items but makes it harder to plan.
Strength, stacking, and weather
Plastic totes hold their shape when stacked and are not bothered by a rainy moving day or a damp garage. Cardboard can soften with moisture and can crush under weight, especially when boxes are reused for several moves. Uniform totes also stack neatly in a truck or a storage unit.
Tip: Whatever you use, put heavy things on the bottom and lighter things on top, both inside each container and in the stack.
Cleanup after the move
This is where totes shine. When you are unpacked, the business picks the totes up. With cardboard you need to break down every box and recycle it, store it, or find someone who wants it.
Cardboard is very recyclable. The EPA notes that corrugated boxes are among the most frequently recycled packaging products. The EPA also says products should only be recycled if they cannot be reduced or reused, and its waste management hierarchy puts reducing and reusing ahead of recycling. Renting reusable totes is one simple way to reuse instead of buying new packing material for each move.
When cardboard still makes sense
- You need to keep items packed for a long time and do not want a rental clock running.
- You are shipping items, not just moving them across town.
- You have unusual shapes, like lamps or framed art, that fit better in specialty boxes.
- There is no tote rental business serving your area yet.
Plenty of people mix the two: totes for most of the home, plus a few specialty boxes for odd items. That works fine.
Cost: compare the whole picture
Prices vary by business and by area, so the best way to compare is to look at real packages near you. When you compare, include everything cardboard needs: the boxes themselves, tape, and your time to build, close, and break them down. Tote packages on Toteable show what is included, the rental period, and the cost of any extra weeks.
Search by ZIP to see local packages, or use the tote calculator to estimate how many you need first.
Frequently asked questions
Are plastic moving totes really better than boxes?
For many moves they are easier: no assembly, no tape, sturdy stacking, and pickup when you are done. Cardboard is still a good choice for long term storage, shipping, and odd shaped items.
Do I need tape for rental totes?
Usually not. Most rental totes have attached lids that close on their own. Some businesses include zip ties or labels, so check the package details.
Is renting totes better for the environment?
Reusing is generally preferred over recycling in the EPA waste management hierarchy, and rental totes are reused from move to move. Cardboard is also widely recycled, so either option can be handled responsibly.
Can I keep totes longer than the rental period?
Many packages offer extra weeks for an added cost. The package shows the included rental period and the extra week price when the business offers one.
Sources
- US EPA: Containers and Packaging: Product-Specific Data
Notes that corrugated boxes are among the most frequently recycled packaging products.
- US EPA: Recycling Basics and Benefits
Says products should only be recycled if they cannot be reduced or reused.
- US EPA: Sustainable Materials Management: Non-Hazardous Materials and Waste Management Hierarchy
Ranks source reduction and reuse as the most preferred approaches.